In a blog post earlier this year, we discussed why EVALI (E-cigarette or Vaping Product Use Associated Lung Injury) may be the next big mass tort. According to the CDC, there have been over 2,800 reported cases of EVALI with 68 confirmed deaths as of February. With so many reported cases, companies in the vaping industry face potentially significant liabilities in the tort system.Companies all along the supply chain are at risk, including manufacturers of vaping devices, batteries, and juices. Distributors of these products, grocery and convenience stores that sell them, and even mom and pop smoking and vaping stores that sell DIY vaping liquids and other vaping products are also at risk.
With all of this in mind, there are many actions companies associated with these potential liabilities should take to prepare for the future. In our previous post, we talked about how companies can ensure they have the data they need to proactively manage their claims and pursue any insurance recovery should this become a mass tort. Here, we will discuss some steps that companies facing vaping liabilities can take to understand their insurance policies that may prove invaluable.
According to the CDC, vaping use (especially among teens) has increased dramatically since 2007. This means that vaping product manufacturers and sellers need to get their hands on their commercial general liability policies going back a decade or more, depending on when they began making or selling vaping products. As further discussed below, EVALI suits could trigger policies across several years so policies providing coverage at any point along the time of your involvement with vaping could be in play. If you do not have your policies readily at hand, your broker should have copies available.
Since there could be dozens or even hundreds of policies to manage, we also recommend capturing your basic policy information (insurer, policy number, dates, limits, deductibles or retentions, attachment point) in an electronic format with a link to an electronic copy of the policy file. A spreadsheet might suffice, and a relational database would be even better. Once you have your policies organized, there are some key terms and exclusions you should identify to realize the true value of your coverage portfolio. Securing the services of an experienced insurance coverage attorney is probably a good idea, too.
Reviewing an insurance policy for coverage starts by understanding certain rules and terminology defined in the policy.
It is also important to understand what types of claims may be excluded outright in the policies. Policy language for exclusions can vary in important ways, so it is important to understand each policy’s limitations separately.
Determining which policies may respond to EVALI suits is a more difficult process that one might expect. Does the use of vaping products trigger all policies in effect during the period of use, or are only the policies enforced when the EVALI manifests? One step is to determine whether an insured’s policies provide coverage on a claims-made or an occurrence basis. Claims-made policies have discrete triggers by nature that require the claim to be filed during the policy period, reporting period (a period of time that claims-made policies will define in the policy), or an extended reporting period (if purchased by the insured). They are typically also limited to acts or injuries that occurred on or after a stated retroactive date. Occurrence-based policies are triggered by bodily injury or property damage occurring during the policy period, even if the insured did not become aware of such injury until after the policy expired.
It is important to know exactly how the policy defines an occurrence to realize the full amount of potentially available coverage. Information on this is located in the definition of bodily injury, the definition of occurrence, and any other occurrence deemer language located in the policy.
EVALI suits continue to be filed nationwide and the vaping industry remains in plaintiff firms’ and regulators’ crosshairs. As the underlying litigation continues to evolve, companies in the vaping industry, even those not yet subject to suits, should consider getting a handle on their insurance to understand whether it might provide critical financial support. As an emerging issue, insurance coverage issues for EVALI suits have not been widely litigated to date making it important for impacted companies to understand their unique policies and stay abreast of current trends.
Never miss a post. Get Risky Business tips and insights delivered right to your inbox.
Nick Sochurek has extensive experience in leading complex insurance policy reviews and analysis for a variety of corporate policyholders using relational database technology.Learn More About Nicholas
Since joining KCIC in 2017, Victor Taylor has worked on developing insurance coverage analysis tools for clients and participating in coverage organization and insurance archeology. He is also experienced in providing claims management support and data analysis to clients with long-tail liability and warranty risks, including developing allocations of costs to insurance coverage, preparing financial reporting, and developing systems for processing claims information. Incorporating advanced process automation and supporting professional development of consultants are key considerations in his work.Learn More About Victor